Diagnosing Bad: Handsome Jack

An owl flapped in through the window and dropped a manila envelope on my desk. It was stamped as being “Urgent,” and inside I found a dossier on a man named “Jack” who had styled himself dictator of the planet Pandora. He was plaguing the vault hunters there, and had a list of atrocious crimes attributed to him. The note enclosed asked me to send a report back on him as soon as possible.

Today’s Villain: Handsome Jack

Background: Handsome Jack is the villain of Borderlands and Borderlands 2, and is a bit of a hero in Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel, although his logic is somewhat questionable, even if his intentions are good.

Image result for borderlands jack

He wants to civilize Pandora by removing all traces of bandits and other riffraff, and while his methods are extreme, his intentions are to serve the greater good and make the planet safe. His plan is foiled, and he winds up blinded in one eye and branded with a relic, punched into his face by a former friend. Additionally, players find out during the game, Jack had been abused by his grandmother as a child.

Image result for borderlands grandma

Diagnosis: Major depressive disorder, recurrent, unspecified severity (296.30), with possibly psychotic symptoms

Explanation: This diagnosis was determined by a process of elimination. Jack demonstrates a variety of  symptoms that are seen in many different diagnoses. However, as Jack, prior to “becoming a villain,” appeared to be functioning without mental illness, it is possible he experienced a traumatic event (discussed below), and, couple with a history of early abuse (at the hands of his grandmother) spiraled into a deep depression that  manifested with severe anger, paranoia, and other somewhat psychotic symptoms.

Image result for handsome jack betrayal

After the betrayal by his friends in the pre-sequel, poor Jack lost touch with his good humor – and reality – never to be the same again.

In the Game Theory video I referenced last time, MatPat asserts that Jack suffers from borderline personality disorder, which can, at times, result in violent tendencies (in some people), and Jack does manifest a few of the symptoms. However, one of the main impairments in BPD is in a person’s sense of themselves: they must either have unclear or unstable goals for themselves, or a poor sense of self/dissociation with the self under stress, and as far as I can tell, Jack doesn’t present with these symptoms.

His mask – in my opinion – would stem more from the fact that his face is disfigured, a la Phantom of the Opera‘s use of mask, moreso than having an overall low opinion of himself. Sometimes you need to separate someone’s personality (e.g., being conscious of how they look) with actual symptoms, which is a tricky game.

Image result for phantom of the opera mask

Jack appears to be severely paranoid, angry, and not above having bouts of impulsivity and violence. He purchased a diamond-encrusted unicorn, named it ButtStallion, imprisons his own daughter, and is not above strangling people for simply mentioning his (deceased) wife.

However, during the events of the pre-sequel, we see a much different Jack. One who is trying to save people. But after his team betrayed him, and he subsequently found himself kneeling before one of his old friends before she smashed a relic into his face and enabled him to see the future.

Image result for the warrior borderlands

Wait, what?

He saw the future. Which means he saw that he was going to die before Pandora was “saved.” But instead of sitting back and accepting his fate, he instead – recklessly – tried to “save” Pandora in any way possible, lashing out in his anger and betrayal and, ultimately, depression and anger and what he knew was an inevitable fate for him.

This doesn’t excuse Jack for his actions, of course. Prior to being punched with a relic, he seemed okay with wiping out groups of people for “the greater good,” which is more of a philosophic discussion as to whether that constitutes a mental disorder or a strict adherence to one interpretation of utilitarian philosophies, and that is a rabbit hole I’m not going down. Today.

Image result for shrug emoji

Just the (Real) Facts: Depression is not usually the go-to diagnosis for psychotic mass murderers, and certainly most people with depression don’t harm anyone. The ones who do harm usually self-sabotage in some way, either mentally or physically.

However, depression can manifest as extreme irritability or even anger, particularly when the severity of depression is high, and can also manifest with impulse control problems and even symptoms of antisocial personality disorder (what we used to call sociopaths). In a case like Jack’s his depression and hopelessness exploded out of him as he desperately tried to accomplish what he wanted to do, but with the added weight of knowing he was fighting against fate the whole time.

Image result for fate

This is of course not to say that depression causes people to become violent. In most cases, depression manifests as a loss of energy, lowered interest in activities that were once enjoyable, feelings of self-loathing, and a host of other symptoms that most people have heard about before. People with what is colloquially called “walking depression” or “high functioning” depression may have these symptoms but not outwardly show them; that is, they still get up in the morning, go to work, pay their bills, and otherwise are functioning adults, except they are still experiencing the typical symptoms of depression.

Image result for it's complicated

It is normal for people to feel sad, irritable, tired, or even upset with themselves, but it’s when these symptoms start to impinge on your ability to perform activities or daily living or otherwise disrupt your life to a harmful or uncomfortable level that these feelings become an illness.

What do you think? Have I changed your view of poor Handsome Jack? Is he more psychotic and less depressed than my assessment believes? Let me know in the comments!

**As we all know, folks diagnosed with depression are at a higher risk for self-harming or suicidal thoughts. If you or someone you know has these types of thoughts, please contact the following resources:

In the USA: 1-800-273-8255

In Canada: +1 (905) 688 3711

In the UK: +44 (0) 8457 90 90 90

In Argentina: +54 (0) 223 493 0430**

Thanks for stopping by, and I’ll see you soon!
~ Athena


What’s next? You can like, subscribe, and support if you like what you’ve seen!

– Support us on Patreon, become a revered Aegis of AmbiGaming, and access extra content!

– Say hello on FacebookTwitter, and even Google+!
– Check out our Let’s Plays if you’re really adventurous!

8 comments

  1. Ah, now I see why you did a Borderlands Let’s talk post yesterday! I don’t know the character well, but you’ve certainly peaked my interest in him. And, “ButtStallion”… 😂 But alas, BioWare must come first!

    I also really like how you included the suicide hotline resources for various countries. Depression is a dark beast, and there is ZERO shame in seeking out help if you need it. That’s strength, not weakness. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You got me! haha Yeah he seems like a really interesting guy…. Still! BioWar first 😉

      One of the hardest things to do is ask for help, and the depression monster can make it seem like a much harder task. I hope if someone needs help, and they stumble across this article, they’ll be able to use the information.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. After yesterday’s post I went ahead and watched the video you mentioned. Jack truly sounds like an interesting character, and I do love a villain who starts out as a hero or as a regular person with good intentions. Another thing that convinced me to play Borderlands as soon as possible is that its characters seem to function on a grey and grey morality, and Jack seems like someone who operates on orange and blue morality (as the folks at TVTropes say).

    Going back to Jack’s initial intentions, and related to what you said about depression, self-loathing and irritability/anger, I am reminded me of something I read once about how you must be charitable to yourself before you are charitable to others. The original context of this was an argument against Paul of Tarsus ideas of self-sacrifice, sadly, I can’t remember the author. Nevertheless, I think that in some ways it applies to Jack’s case. Saving society from itself is one of the hardest tasks a person could undertake, doing so while being depressed sounds like a bad idea all around.

    “Prior to being punched with a relic, he seemed okay with wiping out groups of people for “the greater good,” which is more of a philosophic discussion as to whether that constitutes a mental disorder or a strict adherence to one interpretation of utilitarian philosophies, and that is a rabbit hole I’m not going down. Today.”

    I would very much read that when/if you ever write it. Games like Bioshock, Dishonored, Bastion and, apparently, Borderlands are a treasure trove if you want to discuss utilitarianism (and other fun stuff like manifest destiny, American exceptionalism, imperialism, etc.)

    And last but not least, nice “Fate” pic! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That seems like a good description of Handsome Jack’s morality system. And it’s true that as, erm, RuPaul says, “If you can’t love yourself, how can you love somebody else?” But seriously, you need to have something to give in order to be able to give it.

      One day when I watch BioShock (or am able to stomach a FPS long enough), maybe I’ll revisit that idea 😉 Otherwise, I might have to get creative about giving myself an excuse to wax poetic about philosophy!

      Ha! Thanks 🙂

      Like

      1. Hah, I am tickled that RuPaul and Bernard of Clairvaux (I finally remembered his name) are on the same wavelength even though they are separated by almost 1000 years of history. 😀

        The first-person struggle is real! Both the Bioshock and Dishonored universes are interesting as all get out, but I had to watch let’s plays. And even doing that, I still got a bit dizzy watching the Dishonored ones because of the game’s unique mechanics.

        Like

    1. I know, right? It’s so fascinating to think that by knowing the future and trying to fight against it, Jack may have actually enabled it, so, as has been questioned elsewhere in literature, if he hadn’t known, would he have taken the same actions?

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s